What makes an action film great? It sounds like a simple question, but it really isn't. While most movies are judged by the quality of their acting, writing, direction, and overall premise, the action genre isn't always held to these same standards. There have been numerous great action movies that featured some bad acting, bad writing, and outlandish premises.
It's not that conventional aspects of great movies can't help an action film be great as well, but the genre isn't dependent on such qualities. However, when a great action movie does come along, you just know it. It reaches out and grabs you in a way that few other cinematic experiences can.
As difficult as it is for someone to make a great action movie, it is almost impossible for someone to come along and make a great sequel to that movie. The intangible aspects which define the best action films are almost impossible to recreate.
As such, those who attempt to do so more often than not end up producing something that may share the name of a great action film, but is ultimately so bad that it tarnishes that same name forever by failing to come up with even a reasonable answer to the question, "What makes an action film great?"
These are the 15 worst sequels to great action movies.
15. "The Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day"
The story of how the original "Boondock Saints" overcame an initially bad reception and an incredibly limited release to become one of the most beloved action movies ever made is the stuff of Hollywood legend. Whatever Troy Duffy's film about two Irish brothers who decided to take on Boston's underworld lacked in originality, it made up for it in personality. There's an energy about the movie that only exists in passion projects.
Comparatively, "The Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day" is a soulless film. Nearly every aspect of the movie feels like a glorified attempt to recreate the joy of the original film by following directly in its footsteps. You've got another quirky federal agent, another unhinged friend turned assistant, and many attempts at recreating some of the original movie's most notable scenes with decidedly uninspiring results. If Duffy's goal with "Boondock Saints II" was to remind viewers of why the first movie was so great, he accomplished it — by showing them how terrible that movie could have been.
14. "Mad Max: Beyond Thunderdome"
It's funny, but until the release of "Mad Max: Fury Road," when most people referred to "Mad Max," they were typically talking about "Mad Max 2: The Road Warrior." While the original "Mad Max" is a well-made example of a simple revenge film done on a limited budget, "The Road Warrior's" violent road trip through the end of the world was such a frantic masterpiece that it became hard for many people to associate it with the original movie.
There are actually times in "Beyond Thunderdome" when director George is able to recreate the grit and intensity of the first two movies, but they are few and far between. While this sequel sometimes gets a pass from fans who remember some of the excellent fights and memorable one-liners, the truth is that it’s incredibly difficult to watch any other "Mad Max" movie and try to enjoy the entirety of "Thunderdome." It lacks the raw intensity of the other movies in this franchise and tries too hard to create a mythology for the Mad Max character by incorporating traditional Hollywood elements.
13. "Another 48 Hrs."
While the buddy cop genre wasn't necessarily invented in the '80s, it was definitely perfected during that decade. During that time, directors and producers realized that the key to a great buddy cop film was to have two actors with great chemistry play fundamentally different characters who must find a way to work together. One of the best examples of this approach is the 1982 action/comedy film, "48 Hrs." Despite its fairly bare bones script, the movie ultimately succeeded thanks to the onscreen chemistry of Nick Nolte and Eddie Murphy.
"Another 48 Hrs.'" greatest failure is its complete lack of that same chemistry. It's clear that whatever inspired Nolte and Murphy to work together so well in the original movie had vanished by the time this sequel was released in 1990. Neither man looks especially thrilled to be there, which makes a lot of sense when you consider that the movie's "comedy" consists of well-worn jokes and its "action" consists of nameless thugs dying in generic, dull shootouts.
See the rest of the story at Business Insider