The Insider Picks team writes about stuff we think you'll like. Business Insider has affiliate partnerships, so we get a share of the revenue from your purchase.
The Insider Pick:
There is no shortage of fitness trackers to choose from, but after our testing and research, the new Garmin Vivosport came out on top.
Its accurate tracking, sleek design, and advanced features like waterproofing and built-in GPS make it a well-rounded tool for keeping tabs on both your workouts and activities.
The line between fitness trackers and smartwatches is blurring as smartwatches offer more fitness tools. While devices like the Apple Watch Series 3 and the Fitbit Versa are strong choices for tracking your daily activity, we decided to stay in the fitness tracker realm for this guide.
Those looking for a device dedicated to tracking daily activity, workouts, and sleep have a vast number of choices even without including members of the smartwatch family. To help you decide on the best fitness tracker for your needs, there are a few things you’ll want to take into consideration:
- Comfort and design: Since you’ll be wearing your tracker on a daily basis (even to bed if you want to track sleep) comfort is definitely a priority. If it’s not comfortable, you won’t want to wear it often, which defeats the whole purpose of a fitness tracker. The same goes for design. If you have a small wrist, you may want a tracker with a sleek and more understated look. Or maybe the display is most important to you, and you like the idea of being able to read the time and date as well as your fitness stats. Fitness trackers come in all shapes and sizes, so you’ll be able to find one that suits your style.
- Features: Not all fitness trackers are created equal when it comes to this arena. If you’re looking for a no-frills fitness tracker, then one that tracks steps and your sleep might suffice. However, if you work out often or want more insights into how your activity impacts your overall fitness level, a more advanced tracker with a heart rate monitor or a built-in GPS may be the one for you. You should also consider the types of workouts you like to do. For example, if you’re a swimmer, waterproofing is a must. Just starting out on your fitness journey? A device that gives you coaching and goals to work towards may be the extra motivation you need to stay on track.
- App experience: Most fitness trackers are designed to work in tandem with your smartphone, syncing the data collected with a downloaded application. This allows you to gain even more insight into your health and save the information collected to track your progress over time. Unfortunately, not all apps are created equal, and you may find there are some app experiences you prefer over others. It’s important to choose a fitness tracker that gives you a good app experience. Easy navigation and compatibility with your phone’s operating system are a must.
There are many factors to consider, but we also tested multiple devices and analyzed the reviews to find the best fitness trackers you can buy. Whether you’re interested in advanced workout stats, or simply want a general overview of your activity for the day, our list features fitness trackers with a wide range of capabilities so you can find the one best suited to your lifestyle.
Updated on 08/24/2018 by Kylie Joyner: Added personal testing notes for the Motiv smart ring. Updated prices.
Read on in the slides below to check out our top picks.
SEE ALSO: The best GPS watches for running
The best fitness tracker overall
Why you'll love it: The Garmin Vivosport is a great all-around fitness tracker with accurate step counting and heart rate data that can give you an in-depth analysis of your fitness.
The Garmin Vivosport packs an impressive number of features into a sleek band with a color display. I got to test the Vivosport myself and can confidently say that it lives up to the positive reviews it has received and it will be my personal go-to fitness tracker.
The first thing I noticed was how comfortable the Vivosport is for daily wear. I loved the slim design, which is much appreciated because I have small wrists that are dwarfed by most wearables. The screen is a bit small, but the 72 x 144-pixel resolution allowed me to clearly read any information that appeared on the screen, and the color display was a nice added touch.
I like a fitness tracker that can also double as a watch, and within the Garmin app you can choose from different watch faces, so I could decide how I wanted the time and date displayed. The screen was easy to navigate, though I did notice it could be a bit sensitive at times, and it was easy to swipe to a screen I didn’t mean to land on. Overall, this was a minor annoyance, and I would much rather have the screen be sensitive than unresponsive. The screen is always on, too, so you can see the time or your stats without tapping to wake it up.
The Vivosport comes in two sizes: Small/Medium and Large. While it doesn’t come with a lot of style options (you can’t change out bands) it does come in a few different color schemes.
The fact that this tracker has a built-in GPS was a huge benefit to me as a runner. I loved that the Vivosport easily doubled as my running watch, tracking the distance I ran without needing the use of my phone’s GPS. I could leave my phone at home if I chose to do so.
Along with the GPS, it also features heart rate monitoring, VO2 fitness testing, stress monitoring, stairs climbed, steps taken, and sleep tracking. In addition, the Vivosport has built-in sports modes that include running, cycling, cardio training, and strength training. Swimmers can rejoice as well, because the Vivosport is also waterproof. I jumped in the shower with it many a time with no issues.
The battery life is also impressive. While Garmin says it can last up to 7 days, with using the GPS on my runs, I found mine lasted closer to 4 days before I had to charge it.
As far as app experience goes, I found the Garmin Connect app easy to navigate, and loved how detailed the stats were when it came to my daily activity as well as my workouts. I had no issues with it, and liked how neatly everything was laid out on the home page. You can click on each section to reveal a “boatload of stats” as DC Rainmaker says in his review.
The Vivosport also receives smartphone notifications. When turned on, you’ll be notified via the tracker of any reminders, calls text messages, and social media notifications you receive. These can be turned off completely, or customized through the app.
Overall, the customer reviews are positive when it comes to the Vivosport. Like myself, this reviewer loves how it can double as a daily fitness tracker as well as her running watch, while this loyal Garmin customer was impressed with all of the features.
Out of all the trackers I tested, I kept coming back to the Vivosport. It’s an accurate and comfortable tracker with a slew of features that don’t disappoint.
Pros: Accurate tracking, built-in GPS and heart rate monitor, built in sports apps, stress monitoring, long battery life, waterproof, easy to navigate app, smartphone notifications
Cons: Doesn’t have a lot of style options, small and overly sensitive screen
The best no-frills fitness tracker
Why you'll love it: If you’re looking for a simple fitness tracker that doesn’t necessarily have to be worn on your wrist, the Misfit Ray won’t disappoint.
The Mifit Ray’s design takes a detour from the usual fitness trackers that often look more like watches. Instead, it looks more like a futuristic piece of jewelry — but not an unflattering one. Despite veering into the realm of wearable jewelry, it still maintains a unisex aesthetic that will make it appealing to everyone.
Though I typically prefer a tracker that has a screen and can double as a watch, the comfortable and lightweight feel of the Ray was welcome, and I liked that it was something I could wear along with a watch or other bracelets. Style didn’t get forgotten during the design of this tracker. It comes in multiple colors, with different band choices, and the option to wear it as a pendant rather than a bracelet.
The Ray doesn’t have a heart rate tracker, but while this may be a downside to some, it allows it to be worn in multiple ways while still tracking your steps and activity. It also lacks some of the more advanced features of other trackers, like stress measuring or a built-in GPS, but don’t be fooled — the Ray still has plenty to offer. It’s water resistant up to 50 meters, tracks your sleep, receives text message and call alerts, and will automatically start tracking activities like running.
I was skeptical about how accurate the sleep tracking would be, or if it would truly be able to tell if I was running or not, but I was pleasantly surprised. I’m a light sleeper, and it accurately showed the number of times I woke up during the night, and it could also sense when I was on a run, and tracked the time accordingly. I also liked that the Ray doesn’t require any charging. Instead, it’s powered by three button cell batteries that will last up to six months.
Since it doesn’t have a display, the free Misfit app is a must-have to be able to see all your data. The cylinder that houses this data does have a small multicolored LED light that will blink to show you the progress you’ve made, and it will also vibrate and light up to remind you to move or when you’re receiving a phone notification. I found the app well-organized and easy to navigate and liked how I could see all my stats for the day on one screen, and see how I slept on another.
This reviewer loves the design, the accurate sleep tracking, and the ability to use the Ray as an alarm. I also liked this feature — it was far less jarring to be woken up by a wrist vibration than my usual blaring iPhone alarm. Design was also a winning feature for this reviewer, who found it so comfortable they forgot they were wearing it. They also like that they don’t have to worry about charging it.
Some reviewers do argue that the Ray costs too much for what it does, but if you are looking for a simple tracker, it gets the job done while offering a few surprising features you might not expect to find.
Pros: Comfortable design, can be worn different ways, easy to navigate app, step tracking, accurate sleep tracking, automatic activity tracking, call and text notifications
Cons: No heart rate monitoring, on the expensive side for what it does offer
Best fitness tracker for workouts
Why you'll love it: If exercising is part of your routine, you’ll love being able to track your workout in real time on the bright, easy-to-read screen of the Fitbit Charge 2.
The Fitbit Charge 2 is the successor to the Charge HR. The screen on the Charge 2 is now four times bigger, and the touchscreen can be activated with a tap. You can also use the button on the side to go through menu options.
Though it has a bigger screen, this tracker still manages not to be too overly bulky, even on my small wrist. I found the wristband to be extremely comfortable, and love that Fitbit offers a ton of different colors and interchangeable band options.
While I would have liked built-in GPS here, the Charge 2 does offer connected GPS via your smartphone for walking, running, and hiking while you’re outdoors so you do have the option to track your distance in more than just steps.
In addition to tracking steps like any good fitness tracker should, the Charge 2 also measures stairs climbed, calories burned, resting and active heart rate, and offers in-depth sleep tracking. I really loved how the Charge 2 not only tracked when I was asleep, restless, or awake but also showed me which type of sleep I was in: light, deep, or REM. It was also interesting to be able to see where I stood on average with other women around my age within the app.
If you’re feeling stressed, this tracker also offers breathing exercises to help you relax — something else I very much appreciated after a long day of work. The battery life of the Charge 2 also impressed me. I could go almost six days without having to reach for the charger, even with using all the different functions, which include text and call notifications from your smartphone if you so choose.
Diving into more of the workout features, the Charge 2 has dedicated functions for recording a wide range of activities, including running, cycling, cardio, and strength training. Its large display is perfect for tracking your results in real time while working out. I could quickly check my heart rate to make sure I was within the range I wanted to be, and see how far I was into my workout with the timer.
When I’m not running, I’m a big fan of interval training and HIIT (High Intensity Interval Training) workouts, so when I discovered that the Charge 2 has an interval timer option, I was pretty thrilled. It also lets you pause and resume workouts, and if you do forget to start an activity or workout it can automatically detect an activity session and start monitoring it.
Another huge winning point for the Charge 2 is the Fitbit app. Out of all the trackers I tested, I still found that Fitbit has the most user-friendly app. It’s easy to navigate and offers plenty of useful information to help you get the most out of your fitness tracker.
Both the app and the Charge 2 itself have received positive reviews, and it has been a welcome upgrade to those who owned the original Charge HR. If you’re not a swimmer and built-in GPS isn’t important to you, then the Charge 2 is arguably one of the most reliable fitness trackers on the market right now for tracking specific workouts and activities, as well as getting a better overall picture of your daily activity.
Pros: Comfortable design, lots of color and band options, large display, built-in heart rate monitor, in-depth sleep tracking, advanced workout features, real-time workout tracking on screen, long battery life, user-friendly app
Cons: No built-in GPS, not waterproof
See the rest of the story at Business Insider