The Insider Picks team writes about stuff we think you'll like. Business Insider has affiliate partnerships, so we get a share of the revenue from your purchase.
The Insider Pick:
A top-quality baking sheet is easy to handle, cleans up effortlessly, and bakes food without warping or buckling. The Nordic Ware Aluminum Baker's Half Sheet is our top pick because it is cost-effective, won’t warp, and produces evenly baked goods.
A baking sheet is just one of those tools that you need in your kitchen. Whether you are baking cookies, roasting vegetables, reviving frozen foods, or making a fancy jelly roll, you need a baking sheet (also known as a cookie sheet). That's why we've done the research to find the best baking sheets you can buy.
All of the baking sheets in our guide are made of aluminum or aluminized steel. Aluminum is a popular material for cookware because it is durable, resistant to corrosion, inexpensive, and, most importantly, distributes heat evenly. When aluminum is paired with steel to make aluminized steel, you get an even more heavy duty pan, which also tends to cost slightly more. Stainless steel is another popular material, but it does not conduct heat as well and requires more finesse when cleaning.
Pay special attention to the size of the baking sheet you are looking to buy. Though the standard half-sheet size is 18 by 13 inches, companies try to save on materials by shaving fractions of an inch off of this measurement. For most purposes, that's fine, but it’s still important to be aware of a pans’ dimensions.
You'll have to consider whether you want a rimmed or rimless baking sheet. There are benefits to each style. With a rimmed baking sheet, you can cook items that might release juices or roll around without making a mess in your oven. On the other hand, rimless sheets take up less storage space and baked goods slide off easily.
We also recommend buying a cooling rack that fits inside of your baking sheet. This will allow air to circulate around your food, which lends itself to more even baking and roasting.
While researching the best cookie sheets, we examined hundreds of buyer and expert reviews as well as the ratings of dozens of pans. The baking sheets included in our guide have a sturdy construction, bake foods evenly, and are simple to clean.
SEE ALSO: The best cooling rack you can buy
The best baking sheet overall
Why you'll love it: The Nordic Ware Aluminum Baker's Half Sheet is not only sturdy and cooks your goodies evenly, it is also very affordable.
The Nordic Ware Baker’s Half Sheet is made of aluminum, which allows for excellent heat conductivity and makes the pan resistant to rust. The one-inch rim around the pan is reinforced with encapsulated steel to keep the pan from warping due to quick temperature changes or just normal wear and tear.
The overall interior dimensions of the pan are 16.5 by 11.4 inches, and the exterior is 17.9 by 12.9 inches. The sheet is made in the United States and is hand wash only, which may seem inconvenient, but your cookie sheet will last longer if you don't subject it to the dishwasher.
Just about every expert site lists the Nordic Ware Baker’s Half Sheet as the best baking sheet available. Cook’s Illustrated prepared a number of foods on this pan, and the reviewer noted that they all came out evenly and appropriately cooked. It received top marks for cooling rack compatibility, roasting, handling, and baking.
The Wirecutter has been using the Nordic Ware baking sheet heavily for about five years, and the reviewer has found that it has maintained its shape and still produces golden brown cookies. However, the writer did note that it scratches easily, but that's purely cosmetic and doesn’t affect performance. Food & Wine also liked this cookie sheet because cookies baked on it are evenly browned and well-baked on the inside.
More than 3,500 Amazon buyers have left positive reviews of the Nordic Ware Baker’s Half Sheet. One buyer put the Baker’s Half Sheet in a head-to-head test against another popular baking sheet and noted that the Nordic Ware sheet did a better job of evenly baking her cookies.
Pros: Produces evenly baked goodies, resistant to warping, affordable
Cons: Susceptible to scratching, hand wash only
The best baking sheet set
Why you'll love it: The Wilton 3-Piece Cookie Pan Set includes baking sheets for a variety of jobs at a low price point.
What sets the Wilton Cookie Pan Set apart from the other baking sheets in our guide is that you get three rimmed sheets for around $20. The largest pan is slightly smaller than the standard half-sheet at 17.25 by 11.5 by 1 inches. The other sheets are 10.25 by 15.25 by 0.75 inches and 13.25 by 9.25 by 0.63 inches (fairly close to a quarter-size sheet.)
The pans are made of aluminum and covered with a non-stick coating for effortless cookie removal. Each of the sheets has wide reinforced rims on the ends for a good grip. Becuase you get three pans in different sizes, you'll have a baking sheet for every job.
Foodal recommends the Wilton Recipe Right 3 Piece Cookie Pan Set because the reviewer found that the heavyweight material was warp-resistant even at high heats. The writer also noted that the different pans stacked well for easy storage.
A writer at Reviewed appreciated that the shiny sheets were easy to clean and impressively nonstick. The reviewer did note that the pan warped at high temperatures, but the warping dissipated as the pan cooled. Happy Baker Nation, Reasons to Skip the Housework, and Savant Magazine all recommend these pans, too.
About 77% of the people who reviewed the Wilton Recipe Right 3 Piece Cookie Pan Set on Amazon gave it four or five stars. Buyer JoeTaxpayer has used and abused his Wilton sheets for eight months. He even used his to make a caramelized sugar dessert. Despite its harsh treatment, he says the pans still look like new without any warping or buckling. He has since purchased more.
Others say they like the thick, heavy-duty design. One buyer said that she regularly washes hers in the dishwasher and hasn’t had any problems yet.
Pros: Affordable, store easily, durable, set of three
Cons: Some complaints of warping
The best rimless baking sheet
Why you'll love it: If you are looking for a rimless baking sheet so your cookies slide right off when they're done, get the AirBake Nonstick Cookie Sheet.
The AirBake Nonstick Cookie Sheet is unique because it has two heavy-duty aluminum layers with air between them. T-fal calls this insulated effect “micro-dome technology.” Basically, with this design, the temperature of the metal that comes in contact with the food is reduced, which leads to moister baked goods, no burning, and better browning.
The pan measures 16 by 14 inches, and though it doesn’t have a rim, there is a lip on one side that makes it easy to remove from the oven. Before using the sheet for the first time, spread a teaspoon of cooking oil over the interior to condition it. This cookie sheet is backed by a 10-year warranty.
The reviewer at Kitchn admits that she regularly burns cookies. However, when she used the AirBake Nonstick Cookie Sheet, her cookies turned out golden-brown even though she left them in the oven for too long. She did note that the sheet is a pain to clean since you can’t put it in the dishwasher or let it soak due to the air pockets.
Though Serious Eats didn’t like that the bottom insulation protrusion caused the pan to sit unevenly on the oven rack, the reviewer still recommended this baking sheet because the cookies browned evenly and slid off easily.
Approximately 87% of the reviews of the AirBake Nonstick Cookie Sheet on Amazon are positive. Buyers mention that silicone baking mats and parchment paper are unnecessary with this pan. Stefanie Hudson is a “soft cookie person,” and she found this cookie sheet was perfect for her needs.
Even when making firmer cookies, they still turned out evenly firm throughout. Several people stressed the importance of hand washing the sheet and not letting it soak. If you do get water inside the air pockets, put it upside down in the oven at 250 degrees for about 30 minutes.
Pros: Bakes cookies evenly and burning is unlikely, 10-year warranty, nonstick
Cons: Have to clean it carefully
See the rest of the story at Business Insider